|
|
|
Thucydides
|
o
o o |
You finally made it here! |
Back Next Table of Contents Introduction Links Site Map
Peloponnesian War Pericles' Oration Greece Map Spartan Woman Parthenon Titans Alexander
Thucydides
a biographical sketch
and description of 'the history'
|
Quick Jump
|
|
|
|
The Life oZenithoThe Work o(1.1.1) ?oBetween the Lines oThe Warrior |
| o | Then is Now oWhy This Site o HerodotusoXenophon oName Fits o |
|
|
"Thucydides, an Athenian, wrote the history of the war."
Thucydides was one of those shining stars of ancient
Athens.
Among his peers in that elevated group were:
| the philosophers Socrates,
Plato, and Aristotle
the playwrights Sophocles, Aristophanes, and Euripides the historians Herodotus and Xenophon the sculptors Praxiteles and Phidias the leaders Pericles, Cleon, and Antiphon |
Imagine a scene where these these illustrious men could meet one another as they strolled down the stoned paved streets of Athens. They lived during a time when Athens was at its height. It dominated its 'world' commercially, politically, militarily, and culturally. At the heart of the century was ' the Golden Age ' of Athens. The Golden Age lasted 28 years and is defined by the period when Pericles was influential in the public affairs of Athens (457 to 429 B.C.). Western civilization was born in 400's B.C. Athens.
| While dominance might be enjoyed by those who have it, dominance creates enemies. Enemies who are envious of or fear that dominance. |
The Work:
We know it as The History of the Peloponnesian War. Thucydides himself never gave a title to his work; he only referred to it as 'the history.' As Thucydides told the tale, the dominance that Athens enjoyed was shattered. Sparta won the war.
| His 'history' was a careful and precise chronology of the political and military events of his day. He had access to both sides in the war and gathered notes for years. The actions and consequences of the war were not the work of gods or mythical creatures. Unlike much of earlier Greek literature, this was a true story about real people making real choices. As inovative as that was, it was much more than just that. It is an excellent piece of literature. His writing style had strength and energy. He included dramatic, memorable dialogue into the text like Pericles' Funeral Oration (2.1-46.2). It was one of the first reads that captured the readers' imagination and kept them turning the pages. |
|
|
|
|
by Victor Hanson![]() |
Fortress America: On the Front Lines of Homeland Security by Matthew Brzezinski Heavily armed guards at the entrances to malls and restaurants. Citizens deemed “suspicious” taken away without formal charges or legal counsel. Would a “safe” America even look like America anymore? |
|
|
Buy it!
|
Buy it!
|
|
Then is Now:
ven
more to the point, though, Thucydides had a reason in mind
when he took
the trouble to write an account of the Peloponnesian
War. He had an agenda.
He was an accurate researcher because he wanted others
to
know the facts. He believed
there was value in taking the time to read his
work. He wanted his readers to gain
lessons from them. He wrote the story as
a guide for his readers
to follow (1.22.4-5; 2.48.3).
He wrote it
"not as an essay which is to win
applause of the moment,
but as a possession for all time
..." (1.22.4).
| He provided keen insights into human behavior.
It's kind of like a self-help book or a primer for moral behavior.
Except it's not a small, or elementary, book. A politician, a military
officer, or a commercial leader
of any age can read Thucydides'
and find role models and examples of moral decisions.
A reader can also learn not to follow the examples of poor conduct and bad decisions found in the work. The account was meant to be a word to the wise. Be forewarned. For the story of golden Athens ended in defeat. And he chronicled how. |
symbol of
Athena
|
Thucydides' outlook on life was that human experience
is constant. He thought behaviors
are repeatable and, therefore, predictable. So,
whenever other people find themselves
in similar situations as the ones in his story, he believed,
they will probably have
the same choices to make and behave in the same way.
People in any age and place.
In order to be of help, he wrote his account of
the war so that a reader could do some
research to find out how the Athenians and Spartans acted
in any given situation.
And, then choose well and act appropriately (1.22.4-5;
2.48.3[?]). Then
is now.
Thucydides emphasized the duality of human experience.
His story was influenced by
the dualistic outlook of the Persian Zoroaster
and the Greek Anaxagoras.
He never let
an opportunity pass where he could spotlight opposites,
contradictions, contrasts, and
poles found in the human experience.
| Sparta and Athens represented two contrasting ideologies, two contrasting
systems of government, and two contrasting worldviews. Sparta had the best land army; Sparta had the best navy. Powerful Athens massacred thousands at Mitylene and Plataea (428 and 427) for daring to leave the Athenian empire and join Sparta's camp only to have its own troops massacred at Syracuse years later (413). |
But, it also dealt with the contrasts and contradictions
of issues that a modern-day reader
has to deal with.
That's part of the reasoning behind why 'Thucydides' is the title of this web site. Accurate research. Precise facts. Lessons for future generations. Be forewarned. Don't repeat the mistakes of the past as Santayana advised. Then is now.
Many of this web site's pamphlets have the same agenda. Of those that are designed like that, each is a case study of a historical event which serves as a forewarning to us today or else serves as a parallel to current events. History keeps repeating itself. Then is now.
Athens was the dominant power of its day. Much like the United States is dominant today. Much like the U.S. today. Athens attracted enemies. What enemies is the United States fostering today? Athens was a democracy and became an empire. Will the United States follow down the same path? Immediately after Athens enjoyed the zenith of its achievements, it suffered great losses. In very quick order. That's the warning Thucydides trumpeted. Will the United States repeat that storyline? Then is now.Aristocratic Youth--
hucydides
was born in 464 at Halimus in Attica
to Olorus and Hegeoipyle
(4.105.1). The young
Thucydides spent much of his time, however, in Trace.
His aristocratic family owned gold mines in Trace.
The miners were slaves. Between
25 and 35 percent of the population of Athens (and its
surrounding lands) were slaves.
Slaves did not meet the Athenian definition of 'citizen'.
When you hear of the birth
of democracy in Athens and
Cleisthenes'
promise of 'equality for all', keep in mind
that only citizens could participate. The large
slave minority was not included.
In the internal politics of Athens, his family backed
the aristocratic faction
that favored the older, conservative oligarchic form
of government. It was opposed
by the newer, liberal democratic faction.
Democracy was too egalitarian to suit their
aristocratic tastes.
| You've no doubt heard that the famous philosopher, Aristotle, taught Alexander the Great. And, that it was a continuation of a line of education from famous man to famous man. Aristotle's teacher was Plato and Plato's teacher was Socrates. Well, Thucydides was also taught by famous, accomplished men. |
For more
see Xenophon
|
|
When you read The History of the Peloponnesian War, 'connect the dots.' Read what's not always explicit; 'between the lines' if you will. Thucydides came from an aristocratic family that supported the oligarchic faction in Athenian internal politics. He was not a supporter of the democratic faction led by Pericles and his adopted nephew, Alcibiades. Those two were part of the Alcmaeonid family. Now there's an interesting story. Family members were always scheming to stay, or get back, in power. The tale has generations of Athenian rulers including Cleisthenes, the founder of Athenian democracy. And, it sizzles with storyplots of murder, banishment, restoration, and treason. Pericles' father, or others in the family, may have even aided the Persians at the Battle of Marathon (490). The opposing family in this tale were the descendants of Peisistratus, a tyrant who started the ascent of Athens back in the 500's. The saga of the Alcmaeonid family reminds me of the more popularly known medieval Medici family and its competition with the Albizzi and Sforza families. His nephew Alcibiades almost lost his life during the Battle of Potidaea in 432 during the Peloponnesian War. But, a young soldier named Socrates (yes, that Socrates) saved him. In the internal politics of Athens, Pericles, Alcibiades, Socrates, and the democrats were on one side. While Thucydides, his former teacher Antiphon, and the oligarchists were on the other side. Anaxagoras, who had taught both Thucydides and Pericles, was most decidedly not in the Socrates camp. This internal political (and philosophical) debate raged within the walls of Athens while its armed forces battled the forces of the Peloponnesian League without. Thucydides' written history of the Peloponnesian War ends in 411. But, the war itself did not end until 404. Thucydides' home of Athens surrendered in 404. Thucydides died 3 years later. He was assassinated. Killed by...whom? Spartan operators? Athenian political opponents? Most scholars just assume that Thucydides did not live long enough to finish the story to its conclusion. But, I'm struck by the date of 411. That's the year when extremist oligarchic rebels (Theramenes and the former teacher Antiphon) seized control of Athens and created The Council of The Four Hundred. An anti-democrat, perhaps Thucydides wanted the Council of the Four Hundred to be the climax of his story! Perhaps he intentionally stopped there so he wouldn't have to tell about the removal of the council in 410 and the surrender of Athens in 404. Or, at least, he was pondering how to deal with those issues in his story at the time he was killed. |
Just before the war started (fighting never really stopped in Greece), Spartan forces laid waste to the farmland around Athens. Perhaps as a result, in the early days of the war, a plague swept through the city (430-427). Thucydides contracted it, but he survived. Others were not so lucky. Twenty-five percent, perhaps even as much as 60%, of the Athenians perished. Pericles was among the dead.
Cleon and Demosthenes ran the city. They reorganized the army and navy. In 425, an Athenian fleet bottled up a Spartan fleet in Navarino Bay and forced the Spartans to surrender their ships.
| On the heels of that success, though, Thucydides was a key part in a 424 B.C. naval defeat. The Spartan army had rapidly advanced northward through Thessaly to Chalcidice. There, Amphipolis fell. Thucydides was a naval commander in his childhood home of nearby Thrace at the time. He was ordered to send his squadron of 7 ships to try to regain Amphipolis. |
|
|
on map to view maps of ancient Greece and the Peloponnesian War |
Banished, Thucydides went to Peloponnesus. That's why he wasn't around when his former teacher, Antiphon, led the anti-democratic coup in 411. That's why Thucydides didn't return to Athens and write The History of the Peloponnesian War until 404. His sentence of exactly 20 years elapsed in 404, Athens surrendered in 404, and a general amnesty was declared in the wake of the defeat. And, that's why Thucydides was in a unique position to write such an accurate account of the war. He experienced it, and knew the players, from both sides (5.26.5). |
![]()
| Herodotus is known as the 'father of history.' He started the genre. His most famous work is called The History. It was written around 449. It gave an account of the Persian Wars (490, 480 B.C.) between the Persian empire and the Greek city-states. He traveled to many of the lands and cultures described in his work and he heard the tales of each land he visited. Only the last part of it is actually about the Persian Wars. It's James Michener-like in its vast scope. |
Herodotus |
|
|
| When Thucydides died, Xenophon was in Mesopotamia as a Greek mercenary fighting against the imperial forces of Persia. His side lost at the Battle of Cunaxa just west of where the Baghdad International Airport is today and the Greek force, The Ten Thousand, had to fight their way out of the empire and hightail it back . He wrote an account of that heroic flight in a work called Anabasis. Like Thucydides, Xenophon was banished from Athens for a time. So, he joined up with the Spartan forces. He greatly admired the Spartan way of life. |
Xenophon |
If the Shoe Fits:
Since this is a site dedicated to history, I wanted to name it after a historian. The 'big three' early Greek historians came to mind. Herodotus, considered to be the 'father of history,' was too obvious a choice. Besides, his methodology, or lack of verification and liberal use of myths and legends, left something to be desired. I wanted Xenophon because he had close ties with the Spartans, whom I admire, he was a warrior, and he employed a more disciplined methodology. Plus the name sounds cool. But, alas, 'xenophon' was already taken at the Netfirms hosting service!
I found out, though, that Xenophon just added onto Thucydides' original masterpiece. While Xenophon had been a warrior, it turns out Thucydides was too. Plus, Thucydides lived with the Spartans as well (and for far longer than Xenophon did). Thucydides is the father of scholarly research and used accurate facts before Xenophon ever did. Thucydides was one of the first to design his work to be read. Xenophon was a student of Socrates, in the Pericles/Alcibiades camp, whereas Thucydides was a student of Anaxagoras and in the Antiphon camp. Somehow, this makes a difference to me. Finally, Thucydides meant his work to be used as a guide, or a tale of warning, for readers in the future to apply to their own current circumstances. Then is now. This site is meant to be an accurate, informative, 'good' read and it's designed to make history relevant to today. Of the 'big three,' Thucydides was the best choice to borrow a name of all along!
Go get your hands on a translation of Thucydides' The History of the Peloponnesian War
for yourself and read parts of it! In parentheses, I've included information on where to find
the cited material ( book. chapter. section ).
|
by Victor Hanson![]() |
Fortress America: On the Front Lines of Homeland Security by Matthew Brzezinski Heavily armed guards at the entrances to malls and restaurants. Citizens deemed “suspicious” taken away without formal charges or legal counsel. Would a “safe” America even look like America anymore? |
|
|
|
|
|
Landmark Thucydides: A Comprehensive Guide to the Peloponnesian War,ed. by Robert B. Strassler,
NY: The Free Press, 1996.
Everyman's Classical Dictionary, by John Warrington, London:J.M. Dent & Sons, Ltd., 1961.
Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Encyclopedia, ed. by Mark A. Stevens, NY: Merriam-Webster, 2000.
The People's Chronology: A Year-by-Year Record of Human Events. . ., by James Trager,
NY: Henry Holt and Co., 1992.
http://historychannel.com/ search for topics like: Thucydides,Peloponnesian War, Xenophon, Herodotus,
historians, Classical Greece, and literature.
| recycle gif at www.nzwwa.com Thucydides photo in public domain at www.arches.uga.edu/~nbusch/ flying tinkerbell gif in public domain at www.disneysites.com/ bookstand gif at www.oldfashionedclipart.com exploding rocket and animated bookmark at somewhere like www.gifanimations.com, www.gifs.net, or Sea of Animation. library reader and owl gif are royalty free from Softkey CD column-Greek gif from http://www.plaquemaker.com/clip/archtc/Architec.html Herodotus bust-sketch jpg in public domain /flexbot.cs.northwestern.edu/Herodotus/ |
'T' and 'E' letters are royalty free from Starshine's "1000 Borders and Backgrounds" CD Greek writing jpg in public domain from Google Image Search from www.und.edu/instruct/cjacobs/ hoplite helmet from //home.achilles.net ? scrolend gif at www.oldfashionedclipart.com greece map with permission from http://geography.about.com Xenophon drawing from Google Image search at gallica.bnf.fr/themes/ PolMA5.htm |
created by ME, not a corp., 2003-2006
No rights reserved
Site best viewed in MEDIUM text size or smaller
![]()